arson update

Supporters of McLeggan Tip Off FBI to Sasha Graham’s Role in Arson with Mindy Canarick as Graham Now Alleges McLeggan Set Fire to Her Property Despite Couple’s Admission

By Marsh (Edi) Baptise

Previous Arrest Photo of John McEneaney and Mindy Canarick

Sasha Graham, a pornographic actress and ex-addict, and an acquaintance of John McEneaney and Mindy Canarick, created a Reddit page in 2024 in support of the couple, alleging that McLeggan is a federal informant and cult leader. Prior to the fire set on March 2, 2025, Graham had also created multiple websites and blogs promoting these claims.

Valley Stream, NY - New developments have emerged in the ongoing harassment case against Jennifer McLeggan, revealing that her longtime adversary, Mindy Canarick, set fire to McLeggan’s home on March 2, 2025, just one day after being served a wage garnishment order on March 1. The order was pursued by McLeggan after she was alerted by her many supporters to a defamatory Reddit page where Canarick had been actively contributing, alongside her close friend and longtime supporter, Sasha Graham.

McLeggan’s supporters, recognizing the escalating harassment, took swift action, reaching out to the FBI and the New York State Attorney General's office to report the involvement of Mindy Canarick and Sasha Graham in the ongoing defamation and coordinated attack against McLeggan. What started as an online smear campaign soon spiraled into an outright act of arson.

The Reddit page, created by Graham in 2024 under the alias u/TruthExposed2025, was initially framed as a platform to “expose” McLeggan but quickly devolved into a breeding ground for harassment, character assassination, and calls for retaliation. Canarick and John McEneaney eagerly joined Graham’s campaign, using the page as a safe haven to fabricate allegations and openly discuss their vendetta against McLeggan.

However, what began as an online effort to ruin McLeggan’s reputation soon turned violent. Encouraged by Graham’s support and emboldened by the discussions on Graham's Reddit page, Canarick took her vendetta to the next level by setting McLeggan’s property on fire, destroying her garage and classic car in an act of premeditated retaliation.

McLeggan’s supporters, many of whom had followed her case since 2020, had already tipped off the FBI about the Reddit page and the involvement of Sasha Graham and Mindy Canarick, long before the fire. They pointed out that the site was being used to spread false claims that McLeggan was a federal informant and cult leader—an effort designed to discredit her and justify years of targeted harassment.

After the fire, McLeggan’s attorneys subpoenaed Reddit for information regarding the ownership of the page, and the findings irrefutably linked Graham as the page’s creator. Despite her denials, legal records proved that Graham was not only responsible for launching the page but was actively encouraging Canarick’s harassment and defamation campaign against McLeggan.

In a bizarre twist, despite Canarick already admitting to starting the fire, Graham is now falsely claiming that McLeggan set fire to her own property. The sheer absurdity of Graham’s claim only highlights the lengths she is willing to go to twist the narrative, as she desperately attempts to distance herself from the crime that she actively helped instigate.

Sasha Graham is no stranger to controversy in online spaces. By her own admission, she is a former pornographic actress and habitual drug user, details she has publicly acknowledged in various forums. 

Now, as law enforcement closes in, Graham has spiraled into paranoia, making increasingly bizarre and sinister claims. She has alleged that people are trying to have her murdered—a claim that has no basis in reality but conveniently shifts attention away from her own criminal involvement. In yet another fabricated accusation, Graham falsely claimed that McLeggan orchestrated an assassination attempt on a mentally ill woman, misrepresenting an incident where McLeggan’s supporters called the police after the woman made suicidal threats. Rather than accept reality, Graham twisted the event into yet another false allegation against McLeggan.

Meanwhile, Canarick’s role in the arson is becoming increasingly difficult to deny. Before the fire, she openly stated on the Reddit page that she wanted McLeggan to suffer and was seeking revenge. Her rage escalated into action when she set the fire on March 2, less than 24 hours after being served with the wage garnishment order.

John McEneaney, another active participant in Graham’s forum, has remained closely aligned with Canarick and Graham, using the Reddit page to spread false narratives about McLeggan. His involvement is now under scrutiny.

Despite mounting evidence, Sasha Graham is now attempting to distance herself from Canarick, insisting she had nothing to do with the Reddit page. However, McLeggan’s legal team has obtained proof from Reddit’s subpoenaed records, confirming Graham’s direct role in creating and maintaining the page.

Reddit has confirmed that it does not notify users when their accounts are under investigation and is only required to provide law enforcement with ownership details when subpoenaed. This means that Graham has no idea that her role in the smear campaign has already been exposed.

Believing she remains in the clear, Graham continues to spread defamatory claims against McLeggan, now falsely accusing her of setting fire to her own home. Authorities are expected to build a strong case as more evidence surfaces regarding their coordinated campaign of harassment and eventual escalation into arson.

McLeggan, for her part, is not seeking retribution but rather damages for the years of defamation, harassment, and now property destruction caused by Canarick, Graham, and McEneaney.